62.4 F
New York
Thursday, May 9, 2024
Home Blog Page 3

Report: US Holding Up Sale of Thousands of Precision Weapons to Israel

0
An Israeli F-35I of the 5601 Testing Squadron, bearing Mk-84 bombs fitted with GBU-31 JDAM kit, before bunker-buster bombs dropping test, July 2023. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The Biden administration is effectively delaying the delivery of up to 6,500 Joint Direct Attack Munitions, according to The Wall Street Journal.

By: Joshua Marks

The Biden administration has held up the delivery of thousands of precision weapons to Israel amid the Jewish state’s war against Hamas in Gaza, which entered a new phase overnight Monday as Israeli forces began to push into Rafah city.

According to a Wall Street Journal report on Monday, citing officials familiar with the deal, at issue is the sale of up to 6,500 Joint Direct Attack Munitions (JDAMs)—a guidance kit that converts “dumb bombs” into “smart” precision-guided munitions.

Congress was first informed of the proposed sale, worth some $269 million, in January. However, since then, the Biden administration has not moved forward with the deal.

White House National Security Council Spokesman John Kirby on Monday declined to comment on whether any arms sales had been postponed, telling reporters at the White House press briefing that “our security commitments to Israel are ironclad.”

The State Department must notify Congress of an arms sale to a foreign country when the sale’s dollar amount rises above a certain level, but the administration never followed up with the official notification of the JDAMs sale, the Journal reported. This caused “an effective pause” in the deal, current and former U.S. officials said.

“It’s unusual, especially for Israel, especially during a war,” a congressional official familiar with the arms sales process told the Journal.

The reason for the delay is unknown, but the Biden administration opposes a full-scale invasion of Rafah, citing humanitarian concerns.

The IDF began a targeted operation in Gaza’s southernmost city overnight Monday, taking control of the Rafah border crossing, which was preceded by evacuation notices for noncombatants in eastern Rafah, who were directed to a new, expanded humanitarian zone at Al-Mawasi.

The Journal report comes after Axios reported on Sunday that the Biden administration had halted a shipment of ammunition to Israel.

According to the U.S. news outlet, last week’s decision to place the shipment on hold left the Israeli government concerned, as it marked the first time since Hamas’s Oct. 7 massacre that the United States had halted military aid to the Israel Defense Forces.

The White House reportedly declined to comment on the report, while the U.S. Department of Defense, the U.S. State Department and the Israeli Prime Minister’s Office didn’t immediately respond to questions from Axios.

An unnamed Israeli official downplayed the report, telling the Israeli news website Ynet that “the flow continues” and Jerusalem was “not aware of a policy decision to stop it.”

“Even now, a continued series of defense shipments are being sent from the United States to Israel,” the official stated, while acknowledging that “one shipment or another may be delayed.”

Republican leaders responded to the Axios report, with House Speaker Mike Johnson of Louisiana calling it “wholly unacceptable.”

“Israel, our closest ally in the Middle East, is under attack, but the Biden Administration is yet again caving to the pro-Hamas wing of his party. The administration must end this pause immediately,” Johnson wrote.

Former vice president Mike Pence wrote that it “better not be true. America stands with Israel.” While former secretary of state Mike Pompeo wrote that “cutting off military aid to Israel would be indefensible. It would be a betrayal of a close ally fighting a defensive war.”

(JNS.org)

IAF Fighter Jets Strike Hamas Base Inside UNRWA Compound

0
A Palestinian man outside an UNRWA office in Gaza City protests cuts to aid, June 20, 2023. Photo by Anas-Mohammed/Shutterstock.

“Hamas intentionally positioned the command and control position within the vicinity of an active UNRWA location, jeopardizing the Gazan civilians taking refuge there,” the IDF said.

By: JNS.org

Israeli Air Force fighter jets attacked a Hamas command and control center inside a United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) complex in central Gaza on Saturday, the military said.

According to the Israel Defense Forces, which provided intelligence for the strike along with the Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet), the Hamas center “served as central terrorist infrastructure” that was used as a staging ground for attacks on IDF troops in the central Strip in recent weeks.

The strike was “carefully planned and carried out using precise munition to minimize harm to uninvolved civilians,” the military emphasized.

Furthermore, the Hamas base was used to carry out attacks on efforts to increase the distribution of humanitarian aid to Gaza civilians and Hamas oversaw the supply of weapons to dozens of Hamas terrorists from inside the command and control center, including terrorists operating in underground tunnels.

“Hamas intentionally positioned the command and control position within the vicinity of an active UNRWA location, jeopardizing the Gazan civilians taking refuge there,” the IDF said.

The strikes destroyed the operational capabilities of the Hamas command and control center at the UNRWA compound.

 

UNRWA refuses to evacuate from Rafah

Meanwhile, UNRWA said that it will not heed Israeli calls to evacuate parts of the Rafah in southernmost Gaza ahead of a planned military offensive against the last Hamas stronghold.

Juliette Touma, communications director for UNRWA, said that the agency has not evacuated the area and has no plans to do so.

On Sunday, four soldiers were killed and 10 others were wounded when Hamas terrorists fired 14 mortar shells from the Rafah area at Kibbutz Kerem Shalom.

The attack forced the closure of the Kerem Shalom crossing, a major entry point for humanitarian aid trucks in the Gaza Strip.

The military noted that “the launches were carried out by the Hamas terrorist organization near the Rafah Crossing, around 350 meters from civilian shelters. This is another clear example of the systematic exploitation by Hamas of humanitarian facilities and areas for terrorist purposes, while using the civilian population as a human shield.”

In other news, JNS also reported that the head of the United Nations’ nuclear watchdog arrived in Tehran on Monday, where he is expected to speak at a conference and meet officials for talks on Iran’s nuclear expansion.

According to the semi-official Tasnim News Agency, International Atomic Energy Agency Director Rafael Grossi was scheduled to “participate in the nuclear conference and negotiate with top nuclear and political officials.”

Grossi was expected to meet with Iranian Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian as well as Mohammad Eslami, head of the Islamic Republic’s Atomic Energy Organization.

Grossi’s visit comes on the background of heightened regional tensions in the wake of Iran‘s April 14 direct attack on Israel and with the IAEA criticizing Tehran for its lack of cooperation on inspections and other outstanding nuclear issues.

Grossi told German media last month that Iran was “weeks rather than months” away from having enough enriched uranium to build a bomb.

(JNS.org)

What is the Legal Case Against Israel in the ICC?

0
The judges and guests of the International Criminal Court at the opening of the ICC judicial year on Jan. 18, 2019, in The Hague. Credit: International Criminal Court.

“This is a case that has nothing to do with international law and everything to do with political interests,” legal expert tells JNS.

By: Shimon Sherman

For the past several months Israel has been fighting on multiple fronts. One of the most critical theaters of the current war, however, has increasingly been not Lebanon or Gaza, but The Hague.

Increasingly, anti-Israel activists have been investing in lawfare as one of the most effective weapons with which to weaken and delegitimize Israel. According to recent reports, the International Criminal Court is now considering issuing arrest warrants against various high-ranking Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi.

This move is being egged on by a series of countries in the anti-Israel coalition including, most notably, South Africa and Turkey.

“This is a case that has nothing to do with international law and everything to do with political interests,” Avraham Shalev, an expert in public law for the Kohelet Policy Forum, told JNS.

The ICC has never issued an arrest warrant against the leader of a democratic country, and if it follows through, Netanyahu would find himself in the undesirable company of Sudan’s President Omar al-Bashir, former Libyan ruler Muammar Gaddafi and Russian President Vladimir Putin, the only national leaders with arrest warrants from the ICC.

There is currently no concrete statement from the ICC regarding the legal details surrounding a potential indictment of Israeli officials. In 2021, then-chief prosecutor Fatou Bensouda opened an investigation into “possible crimes committed in the West Bank and Gaza” by Israel. Notably, Bensouda decided to set the chronological limit of the investigation at June 13, exactly one day after Palestinian terrorists kidnapped and murdered three Israeli teenagers, thereby launching “Operation Brother’s Keeper” and “Operation Protective Edge.”

In this way, the ICC probe initially sought to “probe Israeli attacks on civilian populations and violations of international law during Operation Protective Edge” without the context of the terrorist activity that sparked the 2014 Gaza war. “In the very setup of the case you can see an inbuilt bias against Israel,” said Shalev.

The current case against Israeli officials is quite broad and will likely look at “Israeli settlement activity, and use of disproportionate force during Protective Edge,” with alleged transgressions from the ongoing conflict likely being tagged onto the already existing case, he explained.

The ICC’s prosecutor, Karim Khan, has made statements regarding Israel’s provision of humanitarian aid and targeting of civilian infrastructure, implying that both might play a role in a future criminal prosecution. In a speech on Oct. 30 Khan said, “ I want to underline clearly to Israel that supplies must get to the civilians of Gaza without delay,” and cautioned Israel to “demonstrate the proper application of the principles of distinction, precaution and of proportionality.”

According to the laws of war, countries are required to allow humanitarian aid into affected areas under the condition that the aid reaches the civilian population and is not being seized by enemy forces.

“There is absolute documentation of Hamas taking over humanitarian convoys and preventing the aid from getting to civilians. This removes the legal necessity for Israel to participate or allow humanitarian aid,” Shalev told JNS.

Furthermore, even if Israel were to enforce a full siege of Gaza, this could still be a legal method of warfare under international law, he said. According to the Geneva Convention and International Humanitarian Law (IHL), “The prohibition of starvation as a method of warfare does not prohibit siege warfare as long as the purpose is to achieve a military objective and not to starve a civilian population.”

Israel’s rejection of ICC jurisdiction, including the territory of Gaza, Judea and Samaria, presents a further legal hurdle, he explained.

The ICC’s jurisdiction extends over crimes committed “on the territory of a State Party [to the Rome Statute] or by one of its nationals,” which does not include Israel but according to the ICC does include “Palestine,” as the Palestinian Authority did sign on to the Rome Statute in its capacity as a U.N. observer state.

The ICC has sought to legitimize its shaky claims of jurisdiction by passively going after Palestinian terror groups in tandem with its case against Israeli officials. Following a visit to Israel in December 2023, Khan said that the ICC was investigating the crimes against Israeli civilians as “some of the most serious international crimes that shock the conscience of humanity.”

A source close to the ICC prosecutor’s office told JNS that “any arrest warrant against Israeli officials will likely come together with warrants against members of Hamas and Islamic Jihad to give the court a balanced image.”

However, the impact of an indictment will likely be far greater on Israel than on Hamas.

“The effect on Israel’s reputation as a democratic country will be much worse than for a fundamentalist terror group like Hamas,” said Shalev.

The case before the ICC is also legally problematic due to the issue of complementarity. The principle of complementarity indicates that “a case is inadmissible before the ICC if it is currently under investigation by a state with jurisdiction over it,” as stated in the Rome Statute.

Multiple cases of alleged international law violations are being tried in Israeli military courts. Khan himself has previously recognized that “Israel has a professional and well-trained military with military advocate generals and a system that is intended to ensure their compliance with international humanitarian law, and lawyers advising on targeting decisions.” Therefore, any case brought against Israeli nationals would first have to prove that the Israeli legal system is incapable of or unwilling to probe the alleged violation fairly.

According to experts, the recent displays of anti-Israel bias at the ICC are not a bug but a feature.

“From the very beginning, the Rome Statute was designed to go after Israel,” Shalev explained. When the statute was being formulated, most of the clauses were taken almost verbatim from the Geneva Convention, with the exception of the section involving the laws regarding population transfer.

Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention specifically forbids the forced transfer of populations to or from an occupied territory. However, at the request of various Arab states at the Rome conference, this definition was expanded to “the transfer, directly or indirectly, by the Occupying Power of parts of its civilian population into the territory it occupies.” Though this expanded definition could have been applied in several cases, including Turkey’s settlement policy in Cyprus and Russia’s transfer of population into Ukraine, this clause has only been used to go after Israeli communities in Judea and Samaria.

“The very formulation of the Rome Statute was designed to criminalize the presence of Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria. Under these terms, building roads, allowing Jews to own property and many other things can be called ‘indirect population transfer,’” said Shalev. “This clause has Israel’s name on it,” he added.

Though ICC arrest warrants would certainly negatively affect Israel’s international standing, it is important not to overstate the legal implications. In its 22 years, the ICC has never had a single successful conviction and arrest without cooperation from the defendant’s host nation. While technically signatories to the Rome Statute, including most European countries, would have an obligation to carry out such warrants, there is a long-standing precedent for diplomatic arrangements being made to skirt ICC rulings.

In other words, even if a warrant is issued, “There won’t be police on the tarmac in Europe if Netanyahu goes abroad,” Shalev explained. “There is a lot of leeway in reality,” he added.

The current conflict with the ICC has led to various methodologies being advanced to counter the growing threat of lawfare. Former deputy attorney-general Roy Schondorf, who led Israel’s efforts to defend itself against war crimes accusations and the ICC for about 13 years until mid-2022, has strongly advocated leaning on complementarity as a legal shield.

Israel can protect itself by “opening an external, independent Israeli state inquiry, to be led by a former judge,” he said. This model was successfully used in 2008-9 by the Turkel Commission, which Israel used to block investigations by the ICC and the U.N. Goldstone Commission Inquiry. Other experts have proposed a more aggressive approach to dealing with the ICC.

“We shouldn’t fall into the trap of thinking that if we cooperate and we show the world we are playing by the rules then sooner or later they will see our perspective,” said Shalev. “Ultimately this is not a question of law; by every metric the legal arguments are flawed. There is a clear political angle and our best bet is to stonewall. Don’t talk to them, don’t release documents and don’t engage,” he added.

(JNS.org)

Israel Closes Al Jazeera’s Local Operation; Calls it “Mouthpiece for Hamas”

0
Eden Golan, winner of the reality show “The Next Star to Eurovision,” during the final competition on the show, Feb. 6, 2024. Photo by Koko/Flash90.

By: Tia Goldenberg and Jon Gambrell

Israel ordered the local offices of Qatar’s Al Jazeera satellite news network to close Sunday, escalating a long-running feud between the broadcaster and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hard-line government as Doha-mediated cease-fire negotiations with Hamas hang in the balance.

The extraordinary order, which includes confiscating broadcast equipment, preventing the broadcast of the channel’s reports and blocking its websites, is believed to be the first time Israel has ever shuttered a foreign news outlet operating in the country.

Al Jazeera went off Israel’s main cable and satellite providers in the hours after the order. However, its website and multiple online streaming links still operated Sunday.

The network has reported the Israeli-Hamas war nonstop since the militants’ initial cross-border attack Oct. 7 and has maintained 24-hour coverage in the Gaza Strip amid Israel’s grinding ground offensive that has killed and wounded members of its staff. While including on-the-ground reporting of the war’s casualties, its Arabic arm often publishes verbatim video statements from Hamas and other regional militant groups.

“Al Jazeera reporters harmed Israel’s security and incited against soldiers,” Netanyahu said in a statement. “It’s time to remove the Hamas mouthpiece from our country.”

Al Jazeera issued a statement vowing it will “pursue all available legal channels through international legal institutions in its quest to protect both its rights and journalists, as well as the public’s right to information.”

“Israel’s ongoing suppression of the free press, seen as an effort to conceal its actions in the Gaza Strip, stands in contravention of international and humanitarian law,” the network said. “Israel’s direct targeting and killing of journalists, arrests, intimidation and threats will not deter Al Jazeera.”

The Israeli government has taken action against individual reporters over the decades since its founding in 1948, but broadly allows for a rambunctious media scene that includes foreign bureaus from around the world, even from Arab nations. It also blocked the foreign broadcasts of the Hezbollah-affiliated, Beirut-based Al Mayadeen news channel at the start of the war.

A law passed last month allows the government to take action against Al Jazeera, Netanyahu’s office said.

Israeli Communication Minister Shlomo Karhi later published footage online of authorities raiding a hotel room Al Jazeera had been broadcasting from in east Jerusalem, which the Palestinians hope to one day have for their future state. He said officials seized some of the channel’s equipment there.

“We finally are able to stop Al Jazeera’s well-oiled incitement machine that harms the security of the country,” Karhi said. His office said it would bar Al Jazeera from operating in Israel for at least 45 days, a measure that can be renewed.

The ban did not appear to affect the channel’s operations in the occupied West Bank or Gaza Strip, where Israel wields control but which are not sovereign Israeli territory.

The decision threatens to heighten tensions with Qatar at a time when the Doha government is playing a key role in mediation efforts to halt the war in Gaza, along with Egypt and the United States.

Qatar has had strained ties with Netanyahu in particular since he made comments suggesting that Qatar is not exerting enough pressure on Hamas to prompt it to relent in its terms for a truce deal. Qatar hosts Hamas leaders in exile in Doha.

The sides appear to be close to striking a deal, but multiple previous rounds of talks have ended with no agreement.

          (AP)

Israel Closes Al Jazeera’s Local Operation; Calls it “Mouthpiece for Hamas”

0
Israel ordered the local offices of Qatar’s Al Jazeera network to close Sunday. Credit: AP/Nasser Nasser

By: Tia Goldenberg and Jon Gambrell

Israel ordered the local offices of Qatar’s Al Jazeera satellite news network to close Sunday, escalating a long-running feud between the broadcaster and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hard-line government as Doha-mediated cease-fire negotiations with Hamas hang in the balance.

The extraordinary order, which includes confiscating broadcast equipment, preventing the broadcast of the channel’s reports and blocking its websites, is believed to be the first time Israel has ever shuttered a foreign news outlet operating in the country.

Al Jazeera went off Israel’s main cable and satellite providers in the hours after the order. However, its website and multiple online streaming links still operated Sunday.

The network has reported the Israeli-Hamas war nonstop since the militants’ initial cross-border attack Oct. 7 and has maintained 24-hour coverage in the Gaza Strip amid Israel’s grinding ground offensive that has killed and wounded members of its staff. While including on-the-ground reporting of the war’s casualties, its Arabic arm often publishes verbatim video statements from Hamas and other regional militant groups.

“Al Jazeera reporters harmed Israel’s security and incited against soldiers,” Netanyahu said in a statement. “It’s time to remove the Hamas mouthpiece from our country.”

Al Jazeera issued a statement vowing it will “pursue all available legal channels through international legal institutions in its quest to protect both its rights and journalists, as well as the public’s right to information.”

“Israel’s ongoing suppression of the free press, seen as an effort to conceal its actions in the Gaza Strip, stands in contravention of international and humanitarian law,” the network said. “Israel’s direct targeting and killing of journalists, arrests, intimidation and threats will not deter Al Jazeera.”

The Israeli government has taken action against individual reporters over the decades since its founding in 1948, but broadly allows for a rambunctious media scene that includes foreign bureaus from around the world, even from Arab nations. It also blocked the foreign broadcasts of the Hezbollah-affiliated, Beirut-based Al Mayadeen news channel at the start of the war.

A law passed last month allows the government to take action against Al Jazeera, Netanyahu’s office said.

Israeli Communication Minister Shlomo Karhi later published footage online of authorities raiding a hotel room Al Jazeera had been broadcasting from in east Jerusalem, which the Palestinians hope to one day have for their future state. He said officials seized some of the channel’s equipment there.

“We finally are able to stop Al Jazeera’s well-oiled incitement machine that harms the security of the country,” Karhi said. His office said it would bar Al Jazeera from operating in Israel for at least 45 days, a measure that can be renewed.

The ban did not appear to affect the channel’s operations in the occupied West Bank or Gaza Strip, where Israel wields control but which are not sovereign Israeli territory.

The decision threatens to heighten tensions with Qatar at a time when the Doha government is playing a key role in mediation efforts to halt the war in Gaza, along with Egypt and the United States.

Qatar has had strained ties with Netanyahu in particular since he made comments suggesting that Qatar is not exerting enough pressure on Hamas to prompt it to relent in its terms for a truce deal. Qatar hosts Hamas leaders in exile in Doha.

The sides appear to be close to striking a deal, but multiple previous rounds of talks have ended with no agreement.

          (AP)

Israel Documenting Hostage Stories Amidst Emotional Testimonies

0
Israeli women who were released from Hamas captivity hold a press conference in Tel Aviv, February 7, 2024. (Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90)

The project is called ‘Hostages Documentation Project’ which will be a collection of testimonies accessible to the public.

By: Sveta Listratov – TPS

Former hostages released from captivity in Gaza along with the families of current hostages shared insights into their harrowing experiences on Monday as the government partially unveiled a project to document their stories.

“There is no justification for the things we’ve been hearing here. If there is such a thing as a free world, it should be on our side without any conditions, trying to free the hostages who are still in the hands of Hamas,” insisted Moshe Or. His brother, Avinatan, was kidnapped to Gaza with his girlfriend at the Nova music festival.

Israel’s Government Press Office partially unveiled its “Hostages Documentation Project” which is gathering testimonies and will be accessible to the general public, academic researchers and the media.

“Why is it so hard to believe that people were actually abused, who saw their loved ones attacked and killed before their eyes? Why is it so easy to believe the words of a terror organization dedicated to eradicating the Jewish people?” said GPO director Nitzan Chen.

“This project is an opportunity to hear firsthand about the unspeakable events of October 7, the time that the hostages suffered at the hands of their captors, the abuse and terror that they underwent.”

During a panel discussion, freed hostages shared harrowing accounts of their experiences, emphasizing the harsh reality of captivity under Hamas.

“Some of the Hamas guards were walking around us in a barbaric manner, carrying weapons and a commando knife, doing things that put us under stress… serious distress…” said 70-year-old Louis Har who was abducted with his family from Kibbutz Nir Yitzhak. Har, a dual Israeli-Argentine national, was freed with Fernando Simon Marman during a dramatic rescue mission in February.

Har struggled to finish his sentences, his voice faltering, his legs trembling as he attempted to compose himself.

What he did confirm was the first-hand testimonies he heard himself about the sexual abuse suffered by men in captivity.

“I heard there were rapes of boys who were raped on purpose in front of the children hostages. It’s a terrible thing,” he said with visible pain.

On hearing Har’s account and witnessing the distressing videos gathered by the project, Malki Shem Tov, father of the hostage Omer Shem Tov, said his heart was shattered by the harrowing revelations.

“There’s no way to express what I feel hearing these stories for over 200 days,” Shem Tov said in a quiet voice. “If Omer hears me I want to tell him we are doing everything to bring them back home.”

Omer, now 21, was abducted from the Nova music festival, where 364 people were killed and 40 more were taken hostage.

Of all the locations attacked by Hamas on October 7, the highest death toll was at the music festival, on the grounds of Kibbutz Re’im.

“As to his abductors, I would like to say, try to be human. Omer is a young man. He has a soul. Don’t hurt him physically and don’t hurt his soul. I hope he is strong enough to make it,” Shem Tov said as tears brimmed in his eyes.

Chen Goldstein-Almog was abducted with her children from their home in Kibbutz Kfar Aza and taken to Gaza with three of her children, ages 9-17 on October 7.

Her husband and oldest daughter were murdered in their safe room in front of Chen and the children.

Goldstein-Almog said encounters with abducted female soldiers, ages 18 and 19, gave her and the children hope.

“In the week they spent with us, they exhibited incredible strength, displaying remarkable resilience in their determination to survive. I can only hope that they still hold onto that sense of hope,” Goldstein-Almog said.

She recounted how one hostage resorted to self-surgery to remove metal fragments from her body.

Goldstein-Almog also shed light on the sexual abuse the hostages endured.

“At gunpoint, they put their fingers in those girls everywhere possible, in such a shocking way. They are demanding from them to do things for them, sexual acts. The girls went through very difficult things there,” Goldstein recalled.

She added that her captors showed no remorse for their atrocities.

“It appears they had long prepared for the prospect of capturing numerous Israelis. Emboldened by their perceived success on October 7th, they discussed future incursions, suggesting we not return to Kfar Aza,” Goldstein-Almog said.

“They said, ‘How many of us do you think will come next time? Twenty-thousand, forty-thousand? We will rehabilitate ourselves and, in a few years, we’ll be back.’ They don’t seem to have anything to lose.”

The event took place hours before the Israeli military launched its long-anticipated invasion of Rafah, Hamas’s last Gaza stronghold.

On Tuesday morning, the IDF confirmed it had seized control of the Palestinian side of Gaza’s Rafah border crossing with Egypt.

“Yes Rafah, no Rafah, I’m not interested in it right now. I want my little brother at home,” said Moshe Or. “The nations of the world should force Hamas to return the hostages. We demand that you intervene not only in words but in actions. There are rules in war, and the hostages should not have been taken captive at all, and now they have to be released, already today, already now.”

At least 1,200 people were killed and 240 Israelis and foreigners were taken hostage in Hamas’s attacks on Israeli communities near the Gaza border on October 7. Around 30 of the remaining 133 hostages are believed dead.

          (TPS)

Supporting Israel in Taking Rafah is Imperative

0
It is incumbent upon the Biden Administration to support Israel’s actions in Rafah, recognizing that such support is not merely an endorsement of military action but a commitment to facilitating a strategic blockade against a terrorist organization that continues to jeopardize the stability of the region and the safety of countless civilians. Photo Credit: AP

The battle for Rafah is a pivotal moment in Israel ‘s war of self-defense against Hamas, a designated terrorist organization by many countries including the United States and the European Union. This conflict has escalated due to prolonged and unyielding negotiations for a ceasefire, during which Hamas has continued its detainment of hostages, seemingly with no intention of their release. These actions occur under the shadow of international politics, with significant implications for both regional stability and global diplomatic relations.

The situation in Rafah is dire and of paramount strategic importance: it is not only a stronghold for Hamas leaders and their military operations but also a critical point for the smuggling of military supplies and the control of incoming aid. This city’s security and stability are thus crucial not only for Israel’s security but for regional stability as well. The control over Rafah could dictate the future dynamics of Hamas’s military capabilities and its ability to negotiate.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s remarks display a resolve that Israel will continue its defense operations irrespective of the pressures and decisions from international forums. This declaration comes at a critical juncture when the Israeli government’s sovereignty and the safety of its citizens are directly threatened by Hamas’ activities, particularly following the tragic events of October 7, where 1,200 Israelis were brutally massacred in the now infamous Hamas attack. Netanyahu’s statement, “If Israel is forced to stand alone, Israel will stand alone,” resonates as a stark reminder of Israel’s readiness to act independently while still acknowledging the global support for its cause from numerous international quarters.

The strategy employed by Israel in Rafah involves meticulous evacuation of civilians to safer areas, followed by military operations aimed at dismantling Hamas’ operational capabilities in a systematic manner. This approach of evacuating then engaging is intended to minimize civilian casualties and prevent Hamas from using civilians as human shields, a practice that has been a significant concern in urban combat settings.

In the face of ongoing hostage situations and Hamas’s controlled responses to Israeli pressures, the efficacy of Israel’s military strategy has been starkly demonstrated. The recent civilian evacuation ordered by Israel in Rafah prompted a swift counteroffer from Hamas, underlining the impact of decisive military action on accelerating diplomatic negotiations. This was similarly observed in November when intense military pressure led to the release of 105 hostages. Such outcomes underscore the argument that substantial pressure can lead to meaningful concessions from Hamas.

Netanyahu’s statement, “If Israel is forced to stand alone, Israel will stand alone,” resonates as a stark reminder of Israel’s readiness to act independently while still acknowledging the global support for its cause from numerous international quarters. Photo Credit: AP

Criticism of these actions by international bodies and countries such as France, which has called the displacement of civilians a crime, highlights the complex humanitarian and ethical dilemmas faced in such military engagements. However, the alternative—combat operations in densely populated urban areas without prior evacuation—poses an even greater risk of civilian casualties, thereby complicating the moral landscape of military strategy.

Furthermore, the stance of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) which has expressed resistance to these evacuations, brings to light the often politicized nature of international responses, where ideological positions can sometimes overshadow pragmatic considerations of civilian safety.

The decision by President Biden to oppose any Israeli military movement on Rafah has been met with confusion and criticism within Israel. This position aligns indirectly with allowing Hamas, a terrorist organization, to maintain a status quo that has been demonstrably harmful not just to Israel but to the stability of the region as a whole.

As the IDF moves forward with its operations in Rafah, the world watches closely. The outcome of these engagements will likely influence not just the immediate tactical situation but also the long-term approach towards handling groups like Hamas and the broader dynamics of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This moment in history illustrates a grim reality that sometimes, in the quest for peace and security, difficult and divisive decisions must be made. Israel’s current actions in Rafah are a testament to its determination to secure its borders and protect its citizens from ongoing terrorist threats, a principle that any sovereign nation holds at its core.

If President Biden truly desires a cease-fire that will lead to a lasting peace and secure conditions for both Israelis and Palestinians, now is the moment to unequivocally back Israel’s right to defend itself against ongoing terrorist threats. Supporting Israel in these critical moments could reinforce a ceasefire scenario where Hamas is compelled to negotiate seriously, with tangible concessions, particularly concerning hostages and the cessation of hostile actions.

Therefore, it is incumbent upon the Biden Administration to support Israel’s actions in Rafah, recognizing that such support is not merely an endorsement of military action but a commitment to facilitating a strategic blockade against a terrorist organization that continues to jeopardize the stability of the region and the safety of countless civilians. Letting Hamas feel the weight of their strategic disadvantages might push them towards a genuine negotiation table, rather than one set on their terms.

Letters to the Editor

0

Facing Reality About Radical Islam

Dear Editor:

Muslims and Jews see their conflict from opposing viewpoints.

Based on history and international law, Jews believe they have the right to live in their ancestral homeland.

Muslims are fighting a religious war. Jews, Christians and other Infidels are Dhimmi. They are to be dominated and humiliated. The Arab term for blacks is Abeed, meaning slave.

The principal of lying to the Infidel to gain an advantage is called Taqiyya and is enshrined in the Koran.

Arabs spread out of Arabia in the 7th century, conquering and occupying much of the known world. They believe any land, once Muslim, is Muslim forever.

Following World War One, the San Remo Accords established mandates for Palestine, Transjordan, Lebanon, Syria and Iraq.

The 1920s saw the founding of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and the rise of Nazism in Europe. The Brotherhood’s aim was and is to spread the Caliphate among the unbelievers.

The leader of the mandates’ Arabs was Nazi war criminal Haj Amin al-Husseini, Grand Mufti of Jerusalem.

In 1947, the United Nations suggested splitting the British mandate, promised the Jews by the League of Nations and Article 80 of the UN Charter, into Arab and Jewish states. The Jews agreed. The Arabs did not and launched the Nakba to ‘drive the Jews into the sea’.

Mandate Jews were called Palestinians. Arabs identified mostly as Syrians or Egyptians. In 1964, the Soviet KGB formed the Palestine Liberation Army. They named Israel, ‘Palestine’ and non-Jews, ‘Palestinians’. Terrorism was their tool to focus attention on the ‘Palestine’ narrative.

Seventy-five years after the establishment of Israel, Islamo-fascists still have not accepted it as a permanent feature in the Middle East.

It’s time for radical Islam and the useful idiots who support it, to face reality and to solve the refugee problem created by corrupt Arabs and the United Nations.

Sincerely
Len Bennett, Author of ‘Unfinished Work’
Ottawa, Canada


 

Nadler Does Not Deserve the Jewish Vote

Dear Editor:

Congressmember Jerry Nadler calling Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu the worst leader of Jews in 2,000 years makes no sense. His words define him as the worst Jewish member of Congress since our nation’s founding in 1776.

Israel has every right to preserve its security by eliminating Hamas. The crises would not have taken place had Hamas not launched its Oct. 7 terrorist attack.

Nadler also lost his way by not supporting securing our own border with both Mexico and Canada. We have no idea how many terrorists, criminals, gang members, drug dealers and pedophiles were among the 7 million illegal immigrants who have come into our nation without being first vetted.

His voting record all too often mirrors that of Congressmember Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) and other members of the extreme left Democratic Party caucus. He was one of only 41 members who voted against House Resolution H.RS 883 that condemned the chant “From the River to the Sea, Palestine Will be Free” as anti Semitic which passed with 377 votes in favor.

Nadler is clearly treif for Jewish voters. Nadler doesn’t deserve a financial campaign contribution or your vote in 2024. Diogenes is looking for a main stream moderate candidate who would be a true friend of Netanyahu and Israel to run against him this year.

Sincerely,
Larry Penner


 

Palestinian Statehood Not a “Consensus Position”

Dear Editor:

Many American supporters of Israel and Israeli politicians are excited about President Trump’s new statements against Palestinian statehood. But there has been lots of disinformation accompanying this praise too. On a popular Jewish news website one analyst wrote that Trump’s comments were “a significant pivot away from what has largely been a consensus position on the conflict among US politicians for decades.”

The thing is that Palestinian statehood hasn’t been the consensus position, either during the entire period since 1948 nor in recent decades. American presidents have favored Palestinian statehood in only 22 of the past 76 years and inconsistently at that.

In 2002, George W. Bush became the first sitting American president to endorse creation of a Palestinian Arab state. But it is not correct to say that Palestinian statehood has been a “consensus position among US politicians” for the past two decades. That’s because while the Republican Party platform did endorse Bush’s position in 2004, 2008 and 2012, the GOP pointedly removed that clause from its 2016 platform and did not restore it in 2020—meaning that Palestinian statehood has not been the Republican Party’s position for the past eight years.

Sincerely,
Moshe Phillips, Pennsylvania


 

Jews Fighting Back on College Campuses

Dear Editor:

On some campuses we have thousands of Jews in Hillel or Chabad. When the Hamas villains take over a campus or shout “ KILL THE JEWS.” where are the counter demonstrations by the Jewish students in mass? This is only the beginning of violence and potential physical harm and even murder. The only message Hamas and all anti-Semites understand is fight violence with violence. The police and the National Guard may be needed, but only learning how to defend ourselves and action in masse by JEWS will stop this insanity.

Learn a lesson from ISRAEL and speak with a loud voice and intimidate the enemy. They say “ we are Hamas, “ We must answer that we are “Israel.” Rabbi Kahane, of blessed memory, was correct in absolutely everything he said. I predicted what is happening now in my numerous books. Learn from history. Never Again means “Never Again.”

Sincerely
Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg
New Jersey


 

Empty Chair for Sen. Chuck Schumer

Dear Editor:

Like many of us, I had an empty setting at my seder table this year for the Israelis being held hostage in Gaza.

I was seriously considering a second empty chair, though—for Sen. Chuck Schumer. Here’s why. Remember when Clint Eastwood, at the 2012 Republican National Convention, gave an address in which he set up an empty chair next to him, which he said was to symbolize what he felt was then-President Barack Obama’s lack of leadership? Sure it was corny, but we all got his point. In my opinion, Senator Schumer is this year’s symbol of emptiness. His attack on Israel’s prime minister showed that he is empty of morals, good sense, and respect for Israeli democracy. By having an empty chair for him at my seder table, I would be making a statement about just how empty he is.

Sincerely,
Moshe Levine
Brooklyn

Radical Ideologies and the Battle for Minds in the US Universities

0
Today, the dictator of Iran, Khamenei, continues to exploit these ideological vulnerabilities. His regime, characterized by its brutality and suppression of dissent, finds perverse satisfaction in the turmoil evident in American universities. Credit: Erfan Fard

Iran, once a beacon of culture and prosperity, now lies in ruins, a stark testament to the destructive power of radical ideologies. America helped it happen, but if it opens its eyes, it can still save itself.

By: Erfan Fard

Unfortunately, American students and some of their defenders often do not fully understand what they are advocating for. Their lack of awareness of radical Islam, Islamic terrorism, fanaticism, Khomeinism, Shiite terrorism, the Muslim Brotherhood, or the transnational terrorist networks creates a fertile ground for the spread of harmful ideologies. This chaotic situation has historical roots in American universities that date back several decades.

During the 1960s and 1970s, Marxist-Leninist leftists, together with Islamic leftists in America, mounted significant protests against the late Shah of Iran, who was, at that time, the United States’ most steadfast ally in the Middle East. In an ironic twist of history, Jimmy Carter praised Khomeini, and the White House went as far as to call him a “holy man.” This marked a drastic and consequential shift in international relations and internal policies in Iran.

Following the tumultuous events of 1979, Iran, a nation with a rich civilization spanning 7,000 years, fell victim to a regime of religious and political Islamic tyranny. This not only endangered its own cultural heritage and population but also posed a significant threat to the stability of the Middle East and global security at large.

Erfan Fard is an American-Iranian counter-terrorism analyst and Middle East Studies researcher based in United States. Fard holds graduate degrees in both “Security Studies” and “Middle East Studies” from the University of London and the University of California, respectively. Fard was a First Author who wrote the official Biography of Jalal Talabani with the authorization of Patriotic Union of Kurdistan in Iraqi Presidency Office in Iraq.

In Washington, a severe miscalculation occurred; the administration believed that by playing the “Islamic card,” radical Islam could be manipulated to act as a bulwark against the Soviet Union. This naive belief overlooked the fact that many Islamic terrorist groups, including those led by figures like Yasser Arafat, were already collaborating with Soviet interests.

This gross underestimation allowed a radical ideology to break free of its regional confines and assert itself on the global stage. The ideology of Khomeinism, empowered by Western miscalculations, took the world by storm. Ironically, Khomeini’s regime began its international campaign with an act of aggression—hostage-taking—which directly contradicted the expectations of those like Carter who had supported him.

Within the United States, several academics and students—names such as Richard Cottam in Pittsburgh, Marvin Zonis in Chicago, James Bill in Texas, Richard Falk at Princeton, Bernard Lewis at Princeton, and Thomas Ricks at George Town—became deeply entangled with the ideologies of the Muslim Brotherhood and Khomeinism. Far from being mere observers, these individuals were actively engaged in spreading the doctrines that supported the regimes they admired. This not only sowed seeds of discord but also betrayed a profound ignorance of the destructive nature of the ideologies they espoused.

Over the past 45 years, the repercussions of these ideologies have been dire. Wars, chaos, and political instability have become more prevalent, replacing what were once opportunities for peace and cooperation. The educational systems, meant to be bastions of learning and enlightenment, have instead sometimes become platforms for preaching and defending reactionary and destructive ideologies. This has not only undermined the academic integrity of these institutions but also compromised the future of many young Americans who remain largely unaware of the true nature of the forces molding their perceptions.

Today, the dictator of Iran, Khamenei, continues to exploit these ideological vulnerabilities. His regime, characterized by its brutality and suppression of dissent, finds perverse satisfaction in the turmoil evident in American universities.

 

The recent protests in Iran, which resulted in the death of 700 people and the blinding and imprisonment of hundreds more, starkly illustrate the regime’s ruthless tactics. Yet, these atrocities seem to find some echo among American student groups that unwittingly champion the causes of such a regime.

This phenomenon raises pressing questions: Do these students understand the nature of the forces they support? Are they aware of the implications of their actions? It is crucial to recognize that the support for entities like Hamas and the display of Hezbollah flags not only contravene U.S. laws, which categorically reject terrorism, but also threaten the very principles of American democracy.

 

The infiltration of radical Islamic ideology into U.S. and European educational and cultural institutions is extensive. These entities have been active not just in universities but also in media, lobbying groups, research centers, think tanks, and even religious institutions.

This long-term engagement poses a severe risk to the democratic fabric of American society, a risk that is compounded by the widespread nature of this infiltration and the subtlety with which it operates.

Moreover, the international media, which could play a critical role in educating and informing the public about these dangers, often falls prey to the same propaganda it ought to critique. The influence of what some might call the “media mafia”—entities that propagate terrorist ideologies under the guise of news and information—continues to mislead the dynamic and creative young generation. This manipulation leads to radicalization, which if unchecked, could have dire long-term consequences for global peace and security.

Furthermore, the ideological battle between radical Islamists and the West is not confined to military or physical confrontations; it is a deeper, more pervasive war that seeks to undermine social norms, cultural heritage, and historical narratives. The youth in America, influenced by these sinister forces, are often caught up in disturbances that risk not only their future but also the stability and security of the nation they call home.

To the youth of America, and indeed to all who value democracy and freedom: it is imperative to look closely at the lessons history offers. Iran, once a beacon of culture and prosperity, now lies in ruins, a stark testament to the destructive power of radical ideologies. The Iranian people live in a state of perpetual turmoil, their resources squandered on sustaining terrorist activities that have brought them nothing but suffering and despair.

Before 1979, the Shah of Iran stood as a friend and ally to America, representing a bulwark against the spread of Soviet and radical influences. However, his overthrow, facilitated by international leftist groups and Islamic fanatics, opened the door to a regime that has consistently fostered terrorism and oppression.

As we reflect on these developments, it becomes clear that the challenges we face are not just about combating overt acts of terrorism. They are about recognizing and countering the subtle, pervasive spread of an ideology that seeks to destroy from within. It is about standing firm against propaganda, recognizing the true nature of our enemies, and ensuring that the values of liberty and democracy are upheld. The struggle is daunting but essential for the preservation of our way of life and the protection of future generations.

Be vigilant and informed. The rights to freely practice religion, speak openly, publish, and assemble are fundamental to our democracy but must not be abused to support the very ideologies that seek to destroy it. We must not allow the noble intentions of these freedoms to be manipulated to propagate harmful ideologies like Khomeinism or to support the baseless claims of autocrats like Khamenei.

In this critical moment, let us recall the wisdom of our Founding Fathers and strive to protect the principles they established. Observing the misuse of these freedoms to promote terrorism and radical ideologies, particularly in educational institutions like Princeton where Hezbollah flags have been seen, is deeply troubling. These actions betray the principles upon which our nation was founded and on which it must continue to stand.

God save America from these threats, both seen and unseen, and empower us to remain vigilant defenders of our cherished freedoms.

(IsraelNationalNews.com)

Anti-Semitic Persecution Always Happens in Stages

0
A letter by Nachmanides to his son, engraved on the Ramban Synagogue in Jerusalem. Credit: Deror Avi via Wikimedia Commons.

In the absence of order, mutual respect turns to suspicion of the other.

By: Rabbi Uri Pilichowski

The stages of anti-Semitic persecution have manifested themselves differently throughout Jewish history, but all followed similar patterns. These patterns are easily discernible, especially in retrospect. After a mass-casualty anti-Semitic event, it’s all too easy to look back at what led up to the crusade, pogrom or holocaust, and trace how events developed from minor hate to major persecution. For Jews to survive the next round of anti-Semitic persecution, however, they need to be able to discern the pattern at its earliest stages.

The 12th-century Jewish philosopher Nachmanides explained the biblical verses that told of the Egyptian Pharoah’s diabolical plan for the Jewish people: “The Israelites are much too numerous for us. Let us deal shrewdly with them, so that they may not increase; otherwise, in the event of war, they may join our enemies in fighting against us and rise from the ground.”

He continued, saying “Pharaoh said he would persecute the Jews wisely so that the Israelites would not feel it. Pharoah placed a tax upon them, as it was customary that strangers in a country contribute a levy to the king. Afterwards, he secretly commanded the midwives to kill the male newborns. Following that, he charged all his people to drown all Jewish babies into the river. Once Pharaoh’s plan was being carried out, the Egyptians would search the houses, entering them at night, and would kill the children.”

Anti-Semitic events and haters seem to follow the pattern outlined by Nachmanides.

Still, most people in the world witnessing early acts of hate aren’t aware that they are seeing an age-old pattern re-enacting itself. Whether it was blood libels that led to pogroms or the Nuremberg Laws that led to the Holocaust, anti-Semitism has always started with more innocuous acts of hate that can easily be brushed off as not too worrisome. During these early stages, it is easy for Jews to convince themselves that there’s no cause for concern.

After the Holocaust, Jews and a good number of non-Jews promised “Never Again.” While many in the world are on the constant lookout for signs that could foretell the next Holocaust, many seek the wrong signs. Instead of early stages of hate, they have their eyes on tyrannical dictators like Adolph Hitler, ghettos like Lodz or concentration camps like Auschwitz. Anti-Semitic mass events rarely replicate themselves exactly; if they did, they’d be easily detected and stopped. Antisemitism follows the same method in the form of early stages and patterns, though it’s never seen in the exact same acts.

It is unlikely that there will ever be an anti-Semitic event exactly like the Nazi German Holocaust. The majority of Jews in Eastern Europe didn’t perceive the problem and assumed that things would get better—or at least, not worse. For the generations following the Holocaust, it is incumbent upon Jews to have the foresight to be able to perceive larger problems to come. The way to do so is to recognize minor acts of hate as the harbingers of larger acts. Short of prophecy or supernatural clairvoyance, there is no sure-fire way of knowing that minor anti-Semitism will turn into major issues, but discernible events that have repeated themselves should cause concern.

The creation of chaos is the first of these signs. What seems like anarchy or rule-breaking is actually a well-thought-out strategy of creating an atmosphere that suspends rational thought and allows hate to thrive. In the absence of order, mutual respect turns to suspicion of the other, and eventually, hate. A second sign is the intellectual class creating justifications for anti-Semitism that disguise themselves as concern for the larger society. A third is the use of media to distort reality and further the narrative of justified chaos and hate. Lastly, division is sown between the non-Jewish society and the Jewish community through the use of false accusations and slander. And gaslighting is used to shield the accusers from charges of fabricating a narrative.

It is important to note that some Jews have always taken the side of anti-Semites, and non-Jews have taken the side of Jews. Often, these two phenomena are used to try to allay fears that anti-Semitism is growing; they should be more a cause for concern than a reason for calm.

Today’s college activities have employed all the classic vehicles of early-stage anti-Semitism. Protesters have sown chaos; they are part of America’s intellectual class and have used their place in society to justify their hate. Protesters have used media, including television, radio, the Internet and social media to spread their message. They sow division by not allowing Jews into their camps and blocking them from the campus. Lastly, they’ve gaslit those who accuse them of anti-Semitism by claiming that they don’t hate Jews. They’re merely standing against the “genocide” in Gaza. They are anti-Zionist, not anti-Semitic.

A careful study of Jewish history and anti-Semitism demonstrates a major cause for concern today. American Jewry must recognize the problem and take steps to stop these early stages from growing. We cannot ignore the situation and hope it simply goes away.

(JNS.org)

Rabbi Uri Pilichowski is a senior educator at numerous educational institutions. The author of three books, he teaches Torah, Zionism and Israel studies around the world.

CNN Article Errs & Misleads on Gaza Humanitarian Aid

0
A screenshot of the graphic included in the CNN article.

By: David Litman

How much food is entering the Gaza Strip? This question has been the subject of much discussion, and even more misinformation, given the political significance of the answer. South Africa, for example, tried to use claims of a “famine” in Gaza at the International Court of Justice to try and force Israel, by judicial decree, to halt its operation to defeat Hamas and rescue the hostages.

It’s thus critically important that journalists covering this question are careful with the facts. Unfortunately, a recent CNN piece falls short in this regard. An April 17 article by Tamar Michaelis, Tim Lister, and Kareem Khadder, entitled “Israel again accuses UN of “excuses” on aid for Gaza — but UN says deliveries facing major checkpoint delays,” errs by presenting inaccurate data alongside misleading data to advance a narrative.

The errors can be found in a graphic supposedly depicting the daily average number of aid trucks entering the Gaza Strip both before and after October 7.

The graphic, and the preceding text, suggest that the daily average number of trucks bringing food into Gaza now (73) is less than half of what it was before October 7 (150).

In fact, the truth is precisely the opposite. Substantially more trucks are bringing food into Gaza today than were a year ago.

Caption: Average daily food aid trucks entering Gaza in 2023

As will be detailed below, the pre-war figure of 150 average daily trucks is unsupported by the actual data, and the real figure is about half that number. Meanwhile, the figure for trucks after October 7 is seriously misleading in that it dramatically understates the number of trucks currently bringing food into Gaza.

 

Inaccurate Pre-War Data

The CNN graphic cites as its sources UNRWA and the World Food Programme. However, the only source this author could track down for the figure of 150 average daily trucks during the first nine months of 2023 is a report by an organization called the IPC Global Initiative, affiliated with a handful of UN and other aid agencies.

The report claims, “Between January and September 2023, a daily average of 150 food trucks entered the Gaza Strip. Between 8 October 2023 and 9 March 2024, this number decreased to an average of 65 trucks per day.”

But there’s a problem with this. The IPC report provides no source or evidence for this figure. In fact, the source referenced in the footnote for the sentence quoted above contains only information about the flow of aid trucks after October 7, not before.

Worse, the figure cited by CNN and the IPC is contradicted by data provided by the main UN agency tasked with tracking such information, the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA).

According to OCHA’s database, the average daily number of trucks bringing “human food products” into Gaza during the first nine months of 2023 was 75.3, about half the figure provided by the IPC and CNN.

At no point does the daily average come anywhere near the figure provided by CNN. Even if CNN and IPC had included the OCHA categories of “animal feed,” “livestock,” and “raw agricultural products” in their calculations, the daily average rises only to 105.5 trucks per day, still far short of CNN’s figure of 150.

CAMERA is not the only one to have noticed the lack of evidence for the figure of 150. Israel’s Coordination of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) unit similarly challenged this claim, writing in response to the IPC, “It is unclear where the pre-war figure of 150 food trucks per day originates. According to OCHA’s dashboard, between January and September 2023, a total 27,434 trucks carrying food entered Gaza through all crossings, which is a daily average of 100 trucks per day (273 days).”[1]

In short, available UN data contradicts CNN’s claim, and suggests the real figure is half that provided by the network.

 

Misleading Data for Deliveries During the War

When it comes to the figure CNN provides for the average daily number of trucks bringing food into Gaza after October 7, the problem is one of framing.

The authors introduce the graphic with the language of “The number of trucks entering Gaza daily is…,” which suggests the figure is reflective of the current state. But the graphic is not an accurate portrayal of the current state of things. In fact, the number of trucks bringing food into Gaza on a daily basis is far higher today than it was before the war. The graphic misleads by including the early months of the war, when comparatively little aid was flowing into the Gaza Strip for a variety of reasons. But in determining the current humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip, what matters isn’t what the figures were in October or November, but what the figures are now.

Using data from UNRWA, the current situation looks very different than that portrayed by the CNN graphic. During the months of March and April, the average daily number of trucks bringing food into Gaza is 124.5, a figure 70% higher than that suggested by the CNN graphic. Notably, this data includes only aid brought in by trucks. Given that substantial amounts of humanitarian aid, including food, has been airdropped into Gaza, these figures understate the amount of food entering the territory.

But not only are the current figures higher than the CNN graphic would suggest, they’re also higher than what they were before the war. Consider the chart below, which compares the average daily number of trucks bringing food into Gaza during the first four months of 2023 and 2024.

Thus, if one was to recreate CNN’s graphic using a more honest, accurate set of data, it would present the audience with a much different picture, that the delivery of food into Gaza is actually scaling up to reach levels significantly higher than during peacetime.

CNN owes its audience an accurate portrayal of the facts on the ground. Unfortunately, in this case, CNN failed to provide one.

[1] The figure is approximately the same as the figure produced by this author based on the OCHA dashboard if all the following categories are included: human food products; animal feed; livestock; and raw agricultural goods.

(CAMERA.org)

The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (CAMERA) is an international media-monitoring and educational organization founded in 1982 to promote accurate and unbiased coverage of Israel and the Middle East. CAMERA is a non-profit, tax-exempt, and non-partisan organization under section 501 (c)(3) of the United States Internal Revenue Code. To learn more or receive our newsletters please visit CAMERA.org.

CAMERA Op-Ed: Brown U Sends a Message that Extremism Works

0
An image posted by the Brown University Students for Justice in Palestine featuring a sign declaring “resistance is justified.”

By: David Litman

At Brown University, extremism works. The tale of how the university’s leadership responded to two very different sets of concerns clearly demonstrates this.

Begin with the first set of concerns raised. Last year, CAMERA authored two reports highlighting serious issues of anti-Semitism and extremism at Brown University. These reports, which contained copious amounts of evidence of faculty and departments systematically indoctrinating students in their radical, political worldviews, were sent directly to Brown University’s leadership, including President Christina Paxson. They documented how university professors, events, and journals were openly spreading blood libels about “Jewish mobs…thirsty for Palestinian blood,” glorifying Hamas and other terrorists, and even teaching students that Jewish identity is nothing but a colonial conspiracy.

Our letters to Paxson not only highlighted these issues, but also made clear our willingness to work with the university to help address these issues in a cooperative manner. We know that students and alumni also raised our reports and other concerns with the university. We also know that Paxson privately acknowledged to some that our reports “reflect broader concerns about whether universities like Brown maintain integrity and balance in their programming and scholarship on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.”

And yet, Paxson refused to publicly engage on these issues. More importantly, she refused to address the serious ethical questions raised regarding anti-Israel and anti-Jewish hatred being promoted at her university’s Center Middle East Studies.

Contrast that with Paxson’s response to the displays of extremism and anti-Semitism pervading the anti-Israel demonstrations on and off campus, including the encampment on the university’s “Main Green” lawn.

That extremism and anti-Semitism, which Paxson was warned about, and which had been fostered by her own faculty members, blew up in her face.

These “anti-Israel” demonstrators have not just repeatedly violated university rules by setting up camp on university property and violating other reasonable policies. They have spent months engaging in hateful, extremist displays.

Just days after Palestinian terrorists butchered and raped their way through Israeli communities, dozens of student organizations described the atrocities as a “just” act and as legitimate “resistance.” At the same time, Brown University’s Students for Justice in Palestine was organizing rallies, where signs openly declared such “resistance” was “justified” and featured calls to free “political prisoners” (i.e., terrorists) and even genocidal slogans. Jewish institutions at Brown have been threatened, and chants of “Glory to our martyrs” – a chant literally glorifying terrorists – have rung out on university grounds, as Jewish students have been subject to an assortment of anti-Semitic and intimidating behavior.

To her credit, Paxson has refused to drop criminal charges against a number of demonstrators who violated the law. That decision should be applauded.

And yet, she caved to their demand to advance a discriminatory boycott, divestment, and sanctions vote against the Jewish state in an upcoming meeting of the Brown Corporation.

Think about these actions.

On the one hand, Paxson refused to publicly acknowledge and address serious concerns of anti-Semitism and extremism brought to her in a professional, respectful manner.

On the other hand, Paxson caved to those who raised their concerns by breaking the law, violating university policies, and polluting the campus with violent and hateful rhetoric.

And to be clear, we know that those professors CAMERA identified in its reports have been involved in stoking this behavior.

It raises obvious questions. Why should students bother composing well-reasoned and well-evidenced arguments? Why should students follow the rules, abide by the law, and engage in respectful dialogue? When seeking change at Brown University, under Paxson’s leadership, those methods clearly don’t work.

          (CAMERA.org)

On Yom HaZikaron: Tears and Remembering

0
Letters to Talia is a collection of correspondence between a kibbutz-born secular Israeli high school girl and Dov. Even though its words were penned decades ago it is a timeless work. The Hebrew edition of the book was originally published in 2005 and became hugely popular, selling tens of thousands of copies. Credit: Amazon.com

By: Moshe Phillips

This year’s Yom HaZikaron, Israel’s Memorial Day, starting on the evening of May 12, will be unlike any in the Jewish State’s history as it is the first since October 7th.

One of the soldiers being mourned this year and that was killed in action on October 7 was named Dov Indig. However, Dov did not die in 2023 he was a casualty of 1973’s Yom Kippur War and his family has mourned him 50 times on Yom HaZikaron before they do so in 2024.

Israel’s Memorial Day, and it is not celebrated with barbecues but with tears of ultimate grief. And as so many Israelis mourn for their precious fallen fathers and mothers, sisters and brothers, sons and daughters, and friends and comrades, it is not the same for Jews outside of Israel. Reading about Dov Indig’s life is one way to bridge that gap.

Letters to Talia is eerily reminiscent of Self-Portrait of a Hero: From the Letters of Jonathan Netanyahu 1963–1976. Both reveal the tragic loss that Israel has suffered by sacrificing its best and brightest on the fields of battle for generations: Nearly 25,000 soldiers will be remembered on Yom Hazikaron this year. Credit: Amazon.com

Dov Indig fell in combat fighting the invading Syrian army on the Golan Heights and was just 22 years old. He was a dedicated yeshiva student and part of the Religious Zionist movement as are a disproportionately high percentage of the soldiers who have fallen fighting against Hamas since last year.

Letters to Talia is a collection of correspondence between a kibbutz-born secular Israeli high school girl and Dov. Even though its words were penned decades ago it is a timeless work. The Hebrew edition of the book was originally published in 2005 and became hugely popular, selling tens of thousands of copies. Unfortunately, somehow the book never achieved the status it so richly deserves outside of Israel. Gefen Publishing released the English translation in 2012. One way for American Jews to share in the mourning this year is to read Dov’s book.

Letters to Talia is eerily reminiscent of Self-Portrait of a Hero: From the Letters of Jonathan Netanyahu 1963–1976. Both reveal the tragic loss that Israel has suffered by sacrificing its best and brightest on the fields of battle for generations: Nearly 25,000 soldiers will be remembered on Yom Hazikaron this year.

Dov Indig fell in combat fighting the invading Syrian army on the Golan Heights and was just 22 years old. He was a dedicated yeshiva student and part of the Religious Zionist movement as are a disproportionately high percentage of the soldiers who have fallen fighting against Hamas since last year. Credit: Ynet.com

Many of the letters in the book center around Talia’s desire to put the Jewish religion in proper context in her life as a modern, thinking young woman, and Dov’s answers to her questions, as well as glimpses into his army experiences.

What makes the book so moving is not just the emotion that each writer attaches to their search for truth, but the commitment they demonstrate to the Jewish People, their love of the Land of Israel, and their faith in the State of Israel.

The topics tackled encompass an entire range of issues from the Israeli surrender of Sinai to women’s rights, and from emigration to the Diaspora to a critique of Western culture. Interrmarriage is discussed as are books as widely disparate as Erich Fromm’s The Art of Loving (1956) and the Book of Job.

Subjects such as religious coercion and the importance of Israeli settlements are written about at length. The depiction of visits to Sinai are vivid, and leave the reader with a better sense of what Israel lost when this vast area was surrendered to Egypt at Camp David.

The reader is left to ponder how these young Israelis could have had more common sense than the politicians who surrendered so much of the lands liberated in 1967 that feature so prominently in the book.

Here are a few random quotes that give a sense of the patriotism of these very young Israelis:

Yom Hazikaron is Israel’s Official Memorial Day for her fallen soldiers and victims of terrorism. Falling either in late April or early May every year, Yom Hazikaron is an especially solemn time marked by ceremonies and moments of silence across the country. This year, it will run from sundown May 12 to sundown May 13 and is followed immediately by Yom HaAtzmaut, Israeli Independence Day. Credit: tikvahfund.org

Talia: I really envy you that you were on the Golan Heights. I love hiking there more than anywhere else in Israel.

Dov: How fortunate we are that we are privileged to be soldiers in the IDF [Israel Defense Forces], which defends the lives of Jews in Israel and throughout the world.

Talia: We thought that our amazing victory in the Six Day War would put an end to wars, and that the Arabs would resign themselves to our existence, but it turns out that we made a mistake.

Dov: I am happy to hear from you that most of the kids hold that it is forbidden to give up Sinai and it is forbidden to be tempted by the promises of the Arabs, who until today have broken all of them.

We may all mourn together on Tisha B’Av and during Yizkor on Yom Kippur, but tragically, it is not the same observing Yom Hazikaron inside the Jewish State as it is anywhere else.

One book to read that may assist you to feel the depth of the loss that so many Israelis feel on Yom Hazikaron is Letters to Talia.

It is our task in the Diaspora to bridge the miles and other differences, and mourn along with our fellow Jews in Israel.

Read Letters to Talia for yourself; you will be moved by the experience. Grow close to Israel and thank G-d for the blessing of Israeli soldiers.

(Moshe Phillips is a commentator on Jewish affairs whose writings appear regularly in the American and Israeli press.)

“OCTOBER 7”: A Theatrical Reminder of a Day That Changed Lives Forever

0
“OCTOBER 7” opened on May 2 and runs until June 16 at the Actors Temple Theater in the storied theater district of the Big Apple. The play offers an unfiltered glimpse into the personal horrors and enduring impact of the events of October 7, as recounted by the survivors themselves.

By Fern Sidman

A poignant new theater production titled “OCTOBER 7” has debuted in New York City, bringing to the stage the harrowing testimonies of those who witnessed one of Israel’s most tragic days. The play, “OCTOBER 7” opened on May 2 and runs until June 16 at the Actors Temple Theater in the storied theater district of the Big Apple aims to offer an unfiltered glimpse into the personal horrors and enduring impact of the events of October 7, as recounted by the survivors themselves.

The production is the brainchild of Irish playwrights Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, who traveled to Israel in the immediate aftermath of the brutal attacks to gather firsthand accounts from those directly affected. Their journey into the heart of the tragedy has culminated in a play that not only tells stories but also challenges the audience to confront the raw realities of such a pivotal moment in history. Credit: StudioJakeMedia.com

The production is the brainchild of Irish playwrights Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, who traveled to Israel in the immediate aftermath of the brutal attacks to gather firsthand accounts from those directly affected, as was reported in The Daily Mail of the UK. Their journey into the heart of the tragedy has culminated in a play that not only tells stories but also challenges the audience to confront the raw realities of such a pivotal moment in history.

“OCTOBER 7” features a wide range of voices, from young to old, secular to religious, providing a tapestry of personal perspectives that together paint a vivid picture of the day’s impact on individuals and the nation as a whole, according to the Daily Mail report. These stories of survival and loss transcend individual experiences, reflecting the collective trauma and resilience of a community in the aftermath of violence.

Actor Geoffrey Cantor, best known as Mitchell Ellison in both Marvel’s Daredevil and The Punisher on Netflix, said, “We committed ourselves as a company to ensure that the authentic voices of these remarkable people are heard so that others might be touched by their humanity and extraordinary resilience. And I have no doubt that you will be.”

The play strives to serve as a reminder of the importance of remembering and acknowledging the full scope of events that day, ensuring that the narratives of the survivors are heard and not eclipsed by the broader geopolitical discourse. It challenges the audience to reflect on the human aspects of conflict, the individual stories behind the headlines, and the profound effects of such events on everyday lives.

One of the most gripping tales featured in the play is that of a police officer who faced Hamas gunmen with nothing but a pistol and nine bullets, as per the information provided in The Daily Mail report. This act of incredible bravery resulted in the saving of dozens of lives, encapsulating the themes of courage and quick thinking under pressure. The officer’s story is not just about survival but also about making split-second decisions that hold the weight of many lives.

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

Another impactful narrative comes from Biliya Michal, a grandmother in her late fifties, who, along with her family, survived the attack on her Kibbutz by hiding on the roof under solar panels. Tragically, her son was killed in their house, sacrificing himself to allow his family to escape. This dramatic and heart-wrenching story is brought to life with the inclusion of real video footage showing the family’s desperate hideout until their rescue by police officer Itamar Illouz, who also figures prominently in the play, as was explained in The Daily Mail report. Illouz, a 50-year-old police officer, defended the town of Ofakim, killing two terrorists and saving numerous lives through his heroic actions.

The play also recounts the experience of Shani Arditi, a 25-year-old who was attending the Nova festival when the attacks occurred. Arditi’s survival story of hiding for hours in a thorny field captures a different type of endurance—the quiet, painful wait for safety. Similarly, it portrays Dennis, an off-duty IDF soldier originally from Azerbaijan, who, despite being shot five times by terrorists in Ofakim, represents the resilience and fighting spirit of those caught in the crossfire, the Daily Mail report noted,

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

Another act delves into the agonizing hours spent by a survivor in a bomb shelter, knowing their spouse lay dead outside. The Daily Mail also reported that this narrative explores the depths of despair and the strength required to endure such knowledge while waiting for rescue.

Despite its focus on tragedy and survival, “OCTOBER 7” intersperses moments of humor, reflecting the indomitable spirit of the Israeli people. These lighter moments are vital, offering a glimpse into the multifaceted ways individuals cope with crisis—sometimes through tears, and sometimes through laughter.

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

Actor Geoffrey Cantor, best known as Mitchell Ellison in both Marvel’s Daredevil and The Punisher on Netflix, said in a statement, “On October 7, terror came to Israel, with a level of precision, and on a scale she had never experienced before. The terrorists targeted civilians, women, children, and peace-loving concertgoers. They committed acts of such extreme savage brutality that they defy imagination. For Jews, it was an emotional atomic bomb, the impact of which sent shockwaves that rocked and shook the souls of our people around the world. Including me.

He continued by saying, “I’ve felt helpless in the face of what has happened since that day. And those who would politicize or justify what happened that day, or even deny that it happened at all, spin the false narratives that have been flying through the ether of social media, screamed on college campuses, and poisoning the reporting of news since the October 8. Israel is constantly demonized, and those who simply believe in her right to exist are now the villains and oppressors of the world. The result is an exponential rise in overt anti-Semitism, considered by some to be just what we deserve. “

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

Cantor added that,” then this came along — the opportunity to do something positive in these turbulent times. Daunting in scope, it has been both an empowering and truly humbling experience.

October 7 is testimony — a collective sharing of traumatic memory. It isn’t political. It isn’t commentary. Our only job was to find the balance between the devastation of what these people experienced, and the incredible force of hope and resilience that they embody, and to share that with the audience through the truth of their words. We committed ourselves as a company to ensure that the authentic voices of these remarkable people are heard so that others might be touched by their humanity and extraordinary resilience. And I have no doubt that you will be.”

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

The play’s creators, Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, have crafted a piece that does more than tell stories—it invites audiences to witness the complexity of human emotions in times of conflict. The diverse experiences portrayed in the play, from tales of unimaginable bravery to those of profound loss and quiet strength, aim to ensure that the horrors of October 7 are neither forgotten nor oversimplified.

As “OCTOBER 7” opens its curtains, it promises to be not just a theatrical event but a communal moment of reflection, remembrance, and understanding of the resilience that defines humanity in its darkest hours.

The cast of “OCTOBER 7” during rehearsals at the Actors Temple Theater in New York City’s famed theater district.

Tickets are sold online at www.october7theplay.com.

“My Friend, Anne Frank”- a Powerful and Unforgettable Book

0
For her book, Hannah Pick-Goslar chose a title memorializing her dear friend Anne and the shared, happy lives they led until shortly after Anne’s 13th birthday party when, as the Nazi noose grew tighter, the Frank family disappeared after telling everyone they were moving to Switzerland. Credit: imdb.com

A story of love, hope, strength and the power of friendship and family, values that survive the horrors of World War II in a most readable book that will have you smiling through your tears.

By: Rochel Sylvetsky

Although I read the book My Friend Anne Frank, by Hannah Pick Gosdar (Penguin, Random House, 305 pp.) several months ago, I put off writing about it until just before Israel’s Holocaust Remembrance Day. It seemed to me a good idea to post a review of this gripping book during the period when many people look for writings on the Holocaust.

But something more happened. In the first few chapters, Hannah (or Hanneli) lives through pre-war events that European Jewry was unable to imagine, let alone predict. And, as fate would have it, I could not have predicted or imagined that the first part of the book would become especially chilling in the light of its similarity to what is happening today to Jews at US universities – and to Jews the world over.

Anne is an important part of Hannah’s pre-war life, and her famous diary gives Hannah the opportunity to tell their stories and keep Holocaust memory alive all over the world

I had a haunting déjà vu feeling while reading the beginning. It was so disturbing to read the vivid descriptions of a carefree childhood in a cultured Berlin home and in beautiful Amsterdam (the city to which Hannah’s loving parents moved, thinking they would be out of reach of the Nazis), then of how Jewish feelings of security changed to fear in the riots preceding the actual roundups of Jews, and how Hannah’s gentile friends ignored her while she faced taunts and hatred on the streets.

A comparison to the pro-Hamas riots at American universities today, and to the Jews harassed, hurt and vilified in the goldene medina cannot be avoided.

Hanneli’s descriptions of Jew-hatred, widespread indifference to anti-Semitism and blatant support for killing Jews in the 1930s have come back to life in full force.

My chaotic feelings were put into order when I watched a zoom lecture in Hebrew on the Holocaust by Rabbi Benny Kalmanson, Rosh Yeshiva at Otniel, an authority on the Shoah and a member of Yad Vashem’s Pedagogical Council of the School for Holocaust Education. The much-beloved rabbi is also the father of Elchanan Hy”d who rushed south and saved at least 100 of Be’eri’s residents on October 7th before being shot and killed by a Hamas terrorist.

Rabbi Kalmanson views what is happening as a Jewish history continuum, proof of the truth of “in every generation they rise upon us to destroy us,” citing many of the massacres, some of them forgotten, suffered by Jews at the hands of anti-Semites. The Holocaust was of a vastly different dimension but not for lack of trying on the part of all the other Jew-haters before Hitler and after his defeat, such as the PLO, Hamas, Iran and Hezbollah for starters. The big difference is, of course, that G-d, Who saves us from their hands, is now doing so through the brave actions of the Jewish people’s own army who arose to fight back. Not a cheerful analysis, but definitely a realistic one, which provided needed perspective to my gut reactions.

For her book, Hannah Pick-Goslar chose a title memorializing her dear friend Anne and the shared, happy lives they led until shortly after Anne’s 13th birthday party when, as the Nazi noose grew tighter, the Frank family disappeared after telling everyone they were moving to Switzerland. As everyone knows, courageous Dutch friends hid them in the “secret annex” until a collaborator gave them away. The unintended impression given by Anne’s diary, since it is only about her family, is that the Dutch tried to save Jews. What is less known is that the betrayer typified Holland more than the Frank’s loyal gentile friends did, that 75% of Holland’s Jews did not survive the Holocaust including 95% of Amsterdam’s Jews, a fact made clear in Hannah’s writing and something that could not have transpired without the cooperation of the Dutch and their police force.

Hannah, whose family had foreign citizenship papers, is also deported, but to Westerbork and then to a slightly better section of Bergen Belsen. Upon hearing that Anne and her sister are in the worst part of the camp, she manages to gather a food package to throw over the fence despite the danger to herself, but she hears Anne’s hysterical screaming when it is caught and stolen by another starving inmate. The second package she puts together through her hungry fellow prisoners’ unbelievable generosity, is caught by Anne, but it is too little too late for the young girl and her dying sister Margot.

My Friend Anne Frank, by Hannah Pick Gosdar (Penguin, Random House, 305 pp.)

Anne is an important part of Hannah’s pre-war life, and her famous diary gives Hannah the opportunity to tell their stories and keep Holocaust memory alive all over the world, but in truth, Hannah herself is an exceptional, heroic and magnificent human being in her own right.

Just a teenager during the war, she deals pragmatically with the inhuman horrors she describes as she faces them, affirming her fight to live, although her heart breaks as her family members die one after another–except for her little sister Gabi who she somehow protects and nurtures till the war’s end.

Just a teenager in gender-separated Westerbork, she volunteers to clean the camp’s latrines so she can see her father every day and learn from his sage guidance until he dies at Bergen Belsen.

Just a teenager when the war is over, she is welcomed by the remnants of her family in Switzerland, but insists on eating only kosher food and thus does not stay at their house.

Just a teenager when she obtains a certificate allowing her to enter “Palestine”, she makes the decision to move to Israel and see to her sister’s care, as well as to help Otto Frank’s crusade to publicize his daughter’s story by telling it along with her own.

Hanneli longs for her friend as she reads the diary, but when she reaches Anne’s now famous words that “in spite of everything I still believe that people are really good at heart,” Hannah says sadly that had Anne been asked about that statement after the war, she would have answered differently.

And when Hannah herself returns to see Amsterdam after the war ends, she sums up the events in her life with wisdom beyond her years: “Amsterdam was a reminder of the terrible lesson I had learned far too early: nothing in life is permanent. A quiet, loving, comfortable existence can be stolen away by the powerful forces of hate.” Is the world standing by as that happens to the Jews once again?

Poignantly, she writes about the yearning for Eretz Yisrael that her father and grandfather shared, is fulfilling their dream when she decides to move to Israel and studies hard to become a pediatric nurse, marries and raises a family. And while the Jew-hatred that rises in each generation certainly is brought to the fore in this book on the Holocaust, Hannah is the living proof of how in each generation, the Jewish people have also risen from the ashes and rebuilt their lives in response.

How did she do it? Can it be that at that point she was the age of those spoiled young Jewish traitors protesting with Hamas-lovers at US colleges – and expecting “humanitarian” food deliveries while they destroy property that is not theirs and threaten Jewish students?

Hanneli (or Lies in Anne’s diary) writes as much as she can about her friend Anne, but we get to know her as well, an incomparable woman whose need to tell the world about the horrific inhumanity of the Nazis and their helpers burns like a fire within her. The fire seems to have been kindled when shortly after the war, recovering from pleurisy in a sanatorium, she is upset that people say she doesn’t look like a survivor anymore and worries (prophetically, it turns out) that no one will believe what happened.

Nevertheless, despite the horrors she endured, she makes sure to write about the kind Jews she met along her way, and to mention the gentiles who helped, such as identity papers provider Dr. Hans Calmeyer (whose story was reviewed on Arutz Sheva) and kindly Amsterdam neighbor Goudsmit, whose son had been a friend of her little sister, and who sent packages to the camp and hid the family album.

Full disclosure. I knew Hannah in real life and feel humble and honored to be writing about her page-turner book. Her daughter, Ruthie, is a friend who lived just around the corner until recently. In my mind I can still see Hannah, proud grandmother and great grandmother, with her erect, tall bearing, always well dressed and courteous, walking down the street to her daughter’s home.

Hannah Pick-Goslar passed away peacefully in 2022 and, luckily for us, just a short while before that finally wrote down her story with the help of loyal and talented author Dina Kraft. It is not to be missed.

Rochel Sylvetsky made aliya to Israel with her family in 1971, coordinated Mathematics at Ulpenat Horev, worked in math curriculum planning at Hebrew U. and as academic coordinator at Touro College Graduate School in Jerusalem. She served as Chairperson of Emunah Israel and was CEO of Kfar Hassidim Youth Village. Upon her retirement, Arutz Sheva asked her to be managing editor of the English site, a position she filled for several years before becoming Senior Consultant and Op-ed and Judaism editor. She serves on the Boards of Orot Yisrael College and the Knesset Channel and was a member of the Israel Prize Committee.

Parshas Kedoshim–Sometimes It’s Just a Hot Cup of Coffee

0
Sometimes, all it takes is a hot drink and a kind word.

By: Chaya Sora Jungreis-Gertzulin

Parshas Kedoshim. “Kedoshim te’hiyu, You shall be holy…” (Vayikra 19:2) To live a life of sanctity. The mission statement of our nation. A message so important, so vital, that HaShem tells Moshe to gather “Kol adas B’nei Yisroel, the entire nation”. A message so integral to us that Rashi relates a Midrash, “Sheh’rov gufei Torah te’luyin bah, That the majority of the essential of the Torah depends on it.”

We may think that kedoshim, living an elevated life is reserved for the lofty amongst us, those with holy souls. But the pasuk tells us otherwise. Kol adas. All of Yisroel. Men and women. Young and old. Strong and weak. Scholarly and simple. Rich and poor. Each one of us has not only an obligation, but the wherewithal to be a kodosh. Each one of us, in our way, can make the world a better place.

How is it possible, one may ask. HaShem created us with a neshama, as we say every day in davening, “Elokai, neshama sheh’nosatah be, tehorah he, HaShem, the soul You gave me is pure…” With a pure soul, one can accomplish so much. How blessed we are that HaShem implants within us the necessary tools to be a kodosh.

Kol adas – everyone. Even the children.

A while ago, a true life story was submitted to Mishpacha magazine by Esther Malka Goldschmidt. Esther Malka was working as a receptionist in a Lakewood office. A very ordinary job, bordering on boring. Oftentimes, she would be looking for “something” to happen. And then, one day it did. A middle-aged, obviously non-Jewish couple, came in to have a meeting with her boss. The wait was long and the woman approached Esther Malka’s desk to make conversation.

“Do you live around here?” the woman asked. “I used to live on Vine Street.” Esther Malka knew Vine Street well. It was the block of the school she attended, Bais Kaila.

The woman proceeded to tell of how she would sit on her porch, and watch the girls going to school in their pleated skirts and light blue shirts. She recalled one girl in particular. A girl who always waved and smiled to her. A girl who even stopped to wish her a good day and chat with her. The girl’s name was Kaila. “Kaila from the Kaila school”, she said.

It was now time for the couple to go in, but not before the woman added, “Kaila was so nice, that when I had a little girl, I named her Kaila.”

A wave. A smile. A good word. Little things that we can all do. Little things that make a big difference. A Kiddush HaShem.

We may not realize it, but a Kiddush HaShem is not just for others. It is also for ourselves. Every good act we do, every mitzva we keep, has an impact on our neshama. It becomes part of our very being. We become better people as a result. We become kinder and more considerate. We learn compassion, love and understanding. We acquire the virtues of patience and tolerance. One who lives his life striving to be a kodosh, comes out a winner, a hero. It is self-improvement at the highest level.

Kedoshim te’hiyu. I think of my father zt”l, who filled his life with quiet acts of chesed. Many of them unknown to our family, only to be found out during the shiva.

At one point, a woman walked in wearing a nurse’s uniform. My sister and I looked at each other, we didn’t recognize her as one of my father’s nurses from the hospital. We looked at our mother. She didn’t seem to know her either.

“Let me introduce myself”, our mystery visitor began. “I am a baby nurse who works for many families in the community. I get recommendations by word of mouth. I overheard the woman I am currently working by tell her husband that the Rabbi passed. As soon as I heard that it was Rabbi Jungreis, I asked if I could take some time off to make a condolence call. I just wanted to share a personal story with the family.”

Intrigued, we were all ears. The baby nurse continued. “Very often, I am taking care of a baby at a bris. After the ceremony, I would go into a private room to care for the baby, while the family would be greeting their guests. At times, it seemed like an afterthought when someone brought me a cup of coffee or a plate of food. By then, everything was cold. But not so when the bris was in Rabbi Jungreis’ shul, Ohr Torah. Soon after the bris, the Rabbi would bring me a steaming hot cup of coffee and a plate laden with goodies. The Rabbi would tell me ‘You are such a special lady — you have a holy job, you are taking care of a Jewish baby, a Jewish soul.’ It wasn’t just the plate of food. It was the kind, encouraging words, the good wishes, the smile of appreciation, the words of gratitude.”

We are now in the midst of Sefira, counting from Pesach to Shavuos, in anticipation of receiving the Torah. It is during this time period that we also mourn the loss of so many of Rabbi Akiva’s students, due to a devastating plague. A plague caused by their lacking respect and love for one another. The plague came to an end on Lag B’Omer, the thirty-third day of counting the Omer. Maharal comments that until Lag B’Omer there are thirty-two days, the gematria of lev, heart. The lesson of Sefira. To love one another. To have heart. To respect each other, as in the word kavod, honor, which also has a gematria of thirty-two.

In this week’s parsha, we are commanded “v’ahavta le’rea’acha kamocha, You shall love your fellow as yourself.” (Vayikra 19:18). To be a kodosh.

Sometimes, all it takes is a hot drink and a kind word.

Shabbat Shalom and Chodesh Tov!

Chaya Sora

Chaya Sora can be reached at [email protected]

This article was written L’zecher Nishmas/In Memory Of HaRav Meshulem ben HaRav Osher Anshil HaLevi, zt”l and Rebbetzin Esther bas HaRav Avraham HaLevi, zt”l